EN

Electric vs Petrol Car Cost Comparison

The figure on the windscreen is the easy number. An electric car usually looks dearer there; a petrol hatch looks like the deal of the week. The running bill tells a different story: pence per kilowatt-hour against a litre of petrol, lighter servicing, a resale curve that does not follow the same slope. Comparing the two on list price alone, or on fuel alone, always leaves half the picture out.

The number that puts them side by side is the total cost of ownership: purchase net of any grant or surcharge, depreciation at resale, energy, servicing, tyres and brakes, insurance, and loan interest if the car is financed. That sum, over five or ten years, is what the form runs — with the annual mileage at which the ranking flips.

Both columns (electric on the left, petrol or diesel on the right) arrive pre-filled with editable averages. Only what is actually known needs correcting; the rest can stay at its default. The result is an estimate, not a dealer quote: grants, road tax and local schemes are typed in by hand, because the formula itself carries none of them.

The two cars to compare

Assumptions shared by both cars

Display only — every figure below is whatever you type, in the currency you pick here. No conversion is applied.

Comparison period
  
Cars

Electric car

If entered, this overrides the depreciation-rate calculation.

Wear is usually faster (weight, instant torque).

Wear is much reduced thanks to regenerative braking.

Schemes vary a lot by country and year — enter the amount that applies to you, or leave at 0.

Finance on a loan (optional)

Ignored unless the box is ticked. Loan term is assumed equal to the comparison period. PCP/leasing, structurally different from a loan purchase, will get its own page.

Petrol/diesel car

If entered, this overrides the depreciation-rate calculation.

Leave at 0 if no surcharge applies where you are.

Finance on a loan (optional)

Ignored unless the box is ticked. Loan term is assumed equal to the comparison period.

Result

Over 5 years at 12,000 km/year, Petrol/diesel car costs £3,974 less than Electric car — that's £795/year in savings.

  • Total cost — Electric car £31,046
  • Total cost — Petrol/diesel car £27,072
  • Cost per km — electric £0.517/km
  • Cost per km — petrol/diesel £0.451/km
Electric car£31,046Petrol/diesel car£27,072gap: £3,974
Total cost of ownership over 5 years, both cars compared.
Electric carPetrol/diesel carGap (electric − petrol/diesel)
Purchase net of grant/surcharge£35,000£25,000£10,000
Energy (fuel/electricity), 5 years£2,040£7,215£-5,175
Servicing, 5 years£750£1,500£-750
Tyres and brake pads, 5 years£975£950£25
Insurance, 5 years£3,750£3,500£250
Loan interest£0£0£0
Resale value− £11,469− £11,093£-376
Total cost£31,046£27,072£-3,974
Cost per km£0.517/km£0.451/km—
Average monthly cost£517£451—

Mileage break-even point. Below 21,215 km/year, Petrol/diesel car stays cheaper; above it, Electric car becomes cheaper. That's the electric car's break-even point in this simulation.

The total cost of ownership formula

Total cost = Purchase + Grant/surcharge + (Energy + Servicing + Tyres/brakes + Insurance) × Years + Loan interest − Resale value

Resale value = Estimated resale price entered, otherwise Purchase price × (1 − Depreciation rate)Years

Cost per km = Total cost ÷ (Annual mileage × Years)

Technical shorthand marked with an asterisk is unpacked in the glossary at the foot of the article.

What total cost of ownership actually adds up

List price is one line. Total cost of ownership* (TCO) is the rest of the invoice: any grant or surcharge at the point of sale, energy, servicing, tyres, pads, insurance, loan interest if the box is ticked, minus what the car is worth when it leaves. Divided by the distance driven — the form works in kilometres, not miles — it becomes a cost per kilometre that two powertrains can share.

TCO = net purchase + running × years + interest − resale

net purchase = list price + grant/surcharge

If no resale figure is typed, depreciation* is compounded. Twenty percent a year for five years does not leave zero. It leaves 0.805 of the purchase price — a little under a third.

Resale = Price × (1−rate) n

On a £35,000 car at 20% a year, about £11,500 is left after five years. At 15%, nearer £15,500. Four thousand pounds of resale gap moves the break-even by several thousand miles a year. The form does not look up CAP or Glass's. It applies the rate that is typed, or a valuer's figure if one is pasted in. The default insurance pair (£750 electric, £700 petrol) is a polite gap, not a quote. Body-repair labour, ADAS calibration and a shortage of courtesy EVs have all fed premiums; 10 to 30% above the petrol equivalent on a comprehensive policy is not unusual. Two real quotes beat a cloned tenner.

What the sum leaves out: a contract-hire rental, company-car tax, a magic mix of chargers, the wallbox invoice, a ULEZ day, grams of CO2. Money is added here, not a carbon ledger. The two columns are kept apart on purpose.

The output is an estimate, not a dealer quotation and not tax advice. Grants, VED* and local schemes are typed in by hand. The formula is universal; no dated UK scale is baked in.

Why used EVs used to shed value faster

Resale can be as large a slice of TCO as the energy bill. For several model years, electric cars shed a bigger share of list than the petrol or diesel they sat next to. Not because the pack “died” at 40,000 miles. The market moved that way.

  • Range and charging jumped every model year. A 2019 car looked old in 2022 the moment the successor brought 280 miles and a faster CCS curve.
  • New EVs were grant-backed. Used stock sat next to a discounted new one, and asking prices had to fall to stay on the forecourt.
  • Buyers feared the pack. Thin data, thin price guides, hard bargaining even when the cells were fine.

That gap is closing. Eight-year / 100,000-mile pack warranties transfer with the car, so a three-year-old still has cover left. PCP and contract-hire returns at 36 and 48 months have filled the used boards; the guides finally have sales to chew on. A pack charged kindly — kept out of the top and bottom of the state-of-charge range, not hammered on rapids every working day — ages slower than the pub version of the story. Still, this page does not know CAP for a particular hatchback. A hopeful 8% “because a forum said so” will make the TCO lie.

A flat annual rate is a hatchet. Real curves are steeper in year one and gentler later. A single percentage remains a useful order of magnitude, not a valuer's certificate. For a used car, remaining SOH* belongs in the asking price or the resale box, not in a hidden slider. A printout from a dealer or an independent tester is worth more than a polished MOT.

Annual mileage is what flips the ranking

The break-even km/year in the results is a single question: with these prices, when does the EV overtake. It is not a slogan that “EVs always win above 12,000 miles”.

  • Low miles, short hops — the extra purchase price takes years to earn back, cheap overnight electricity or not.
  • A commute, charge on the drive — where running cost does the heavy lifting, and the threshold drops.
  • Motorway every week, public rapid — the pence per kWh eat the gap. A frugal diesel re-enters the fight.

Fixed cost (purchase, grant or surcharge, insurance, servicing, tyres, pads, interest, minus resale) is split from variable cost per kilometre (energy only). The threshold is that gap in fixed cost, divided by years times the gap per kilometre.

threshold (km/year) = fixed-cost gap ÷ (years × cost-per-km gap)

Shift the annual miles and run it again. The ranking moves with energy, servicing and insurance, and with whether those miles are eight-mile school runs or 180-mile trunk roads. A diesel that returns 55 mpg on a cruise is a different opponent from a petrol hatch sitting in traffic. The form has one ICE column: petrol or diesel, that car's numbers — not a mash-up of both. In practice it is not a national verdict. It is a snapshot of today's assumptions. The engine counts kilometres; 12,000 miles is about 19,300 km, and that conversion belongs in the box before the compare button is pressed.

Driveway charging versus a rapid on the M6

One kWh* price in the form. That is the lever. There is no hidden 70/30 mix behind the button.

energy cost / 100 km = use (kWh/100 km) × price per kWh

  • Wallbox, overnight unit rate — 15–28 p/kWh is a common UK single-rate band. At 16 kWh/100 km, roughly £2.50–£4.50/100 km.
  • Destination or slow public — higher, and the app fee is part of the pence.
  • En-route rapid — 50–85 p is the going rate, sometimes more. Diesel territory.

Eighty percent at home and twenty percent on a motorway rapid is a weighted average to paste in, not the 20 p of a suburban driveway. A flat with no off-street parking is not the same TCO as a house with a 7 kW wallbox. The default £0.20/kWh on this page is a home-ish figure, not a service-station one.

blend p/kWh = (home share × home rate) + (rapid share × rapid rate)

A single unit rate in the mid-20s is not an EV tariff that might be single-digit pence for a five-hour overnight window and a higher day rate. If nine-tenths of the charging happens in the cheap window, the blended p/kWh is not the day rate. Put simply, the box wants the effective pence of the year's charging, not the slogan on a comparison site. Off-peak versus standard, Economy 7, a time-of-use tariff — that split is the job of the electricity tariff comparison on this site.

PCP, HP and contract hire are not a cash purchase

This calculator is buy, hold, sell — cash or a repayment loan. A PCP*, or a contract-hire rental, is not that shape of deal. Hire purchase* is closer to the loan tick-box on this form; PCP and business contract hire are not.

The finance house sets a residual (the guaranteed minimum future value on a PCP), sometimes wraps in servicing, and charges for the depreciation risk it is holding. If EVs are distrusted, the monthly rises even after a grant has come off the list price. On paper the EV looks cheaper; the balloon says otherwise. At the end of a PCP the optional final payment is compared with what the car is worth on the day, not with a straight-line rate. Walk away, refinance, or pay the balloon — three different money stories, none of which is this TCO minus a monthly seen in an ad.

There is no lease mode here. A purchase TCO and a monthly rental are not subtracted from each other, and a balloon is not “equity” until a valuer agrees.

If the car is rented, the useful comparison is the all-in rental, plus excess miles, tyre clauses and damage, against the same contract on petrol. Mileage penalties on a 10,000-mile contract will eat an EV that “only” does 14,000 as surely as they eat a diesel. Those extras are counted before the monthly is called cheap. Two contract-hire quotes compare with each other; a contract-hire quote and this page do not.

Buying used: the steep drop is already in the asking price

At three or four years the steep drop is already in the figure on Auto Trader. That is the point of buying used.

That price is typed as purchase, and a gentler rate for the years the car will be kept — or a resale number from a guide, not a wish. There is no “used mode” here, and no automatic cull of short-range cars. A pack inside its warranty helps the next buyer as much as it helps the current one. Early 120-mile, slow-charge cars help less: the next buyer may walk, and then resale is a hope. Two used cars of similar age are compared with each other, not a new EV against a 2018 petrol, unless that is genuinely the choice on the drive.

A 2018 petrol with a cambelt due is not “the same money” as a 2021 EV with 70% of its pack warranty left. Both are priced as they sit. A 60 kWh pack at 90% SOH holds about 54 kWh; range and the kWh/100 km experienced both move. Maker warranties promise the pack will not drop below about 70% SOH inside eight years or 100,000 miles. That is a floor, not a forecast. Heavy DC rapid use and high charge stored in heat age a pack faster; gentle AC overnight is kinder. A replacement pack is a four-figure to five-figure job — which is why remaining warranty is worth more than a polished MOT, and why a weak SOH is folded into a lower purchase price or a worse resale.

Grants and plug-in schemes: typed in, never assumed

The UK plug-in car grant is gone for most cars. Some vans still qualify for help; local and devolved schemes appear and vanish. OZEV* domestic wallbox support has closed for most households; a workplace chargepoint scheme is not a house.

The net price actually payable this year belongs in the purchase box, not a 2021 brochure with a grant a dealer can no longer claim. A thermal malus is a French line — it does not apply in the UK. What the UK does instead is VED, and for company drivers BIK, and in some cities a daily charge if the ICE is dirty. Scottish and Welsh top-ups have had their own lives. If a quote still shows a “PiCG”, it is a stale template.

Zero unless money is genuinely coming off, or on, this month. The form does not invent a grant. That is deliberate: a universal formula, not a dated UK scale hiding behind the button.

Benefit in Kind: a different spreadsheet

UK BIK* on EVs has been very low — a few percent of P11D* — against petrol and diesel rates that climb with CO2. That gap can dwarf a higher list price for anyone who takes a car from work. The percentage ticks up on a published ladder, so a quote from 2021 is not a quote for 2027. Vans have their own van BIK rules, and they are not the car table. The driver is not the only person paying: the employer has Class 1A National Insurance on the benefit, and the capital-allowance side can flip a fleet spreadsheet on its own.

This comparator is a private TCO: buy, run, sell. It does not add BIK, National Insurance on the benefit, or capital allowances. For a fleet, those lines can flip the ranking on their own.

HMRC mileage (AMAP*) reimburses the employee who uses a private car for work. It is a published pence-per-mile scale — the same bands for petrol and for EV in recent years — not a true TCO. An EV can be cheap to run and poorly matched to that scale, because the 45 p / 25 p style rates were built around fuel, insurance and wear for a mixed fleet, not around a 7 p/kWh overnight fill. Advisory electricity rates, used when the company provides the power, live in a different HMRC table again. None of which is in the boxes above. For a private buyer this whole section is a sideshow. For a fleet manager it is the show.

Real-world range, WLTP and a working day

WLTP* is not January on the M1. Knock 20–30% off in the cold is common, and worse without a heat pump. Cabin heat comes out of the pack unless there is a heat pump; a PTC heater on a freezing morning can flatten the first chunk of range before the ring road is left. Motorway at 70 mph with a headwind is another chunk. The brochure figure assumed 20 °C and a gentle mix.

A 20-minute stop on a 200-mile run, on a rapid that holds its kW, is fine. Three unplanned calls with no charger and a diary that cannot slip is not. There is no “suitability score” in this tool. It counts money. Business use is a separate question: real winter range, chargers on that loop, a socket at the depot, a spare van if the car is a no-show. Fifty thousand miles a year with overnight charging on the yard is not the same fifty thousand in a pure roaming diary.

That said, a splendid TCO does not replace a diary that holds. Twenty minutes every two hours, on a round already tight, pushes the last client. Neither that fatigue nor the quiet in town lands in the table. A yearly average is still defensible: four winter months, motorway weekends, the rest mixed. That average is what belongs in the box — not 17 kWh “because it was pre-filled”. The comparison is only honest if both columns are: 55 mpg “because Autocar” against 14 kWh “because the window sticker” compares nothing.

Tyres, pads and instant torque

EVs are heavy and the torque is instant. Tyres go quicker than on the petrol equivalent, and EV-labelled rubber (load index, quieter carcass, lower rolling resistance) is not the cheapest option on the shelf. Pads and discs last longer thanks to regen — until a motorway-only car never uses the friction brakes and the discs rust, at which point discs are bought, not pads.

The field is there for a reason. Leave tyres at zero and the EV is flattered; copy the petrol pad budget across and it is punished. A year's average in each box, including a puncture or a sidewall on a pothole if that is the roads, keeps the comparison honest. Weight both columns the same way, or the comparison is theatre.

Even so, £180 a year on the left and £150 on the right is only a sketch. How long a set actually lasts, and what the local tyre shop charges for an EV-rated 18-inch, weigh more than a press-kit figure.

ULEZ, Clean Air Zones and the congestion charge

London's ULEZ* is a compliance charge. A petrol car that meets Euro 4, or a diesel that meets Euro 6, pays nothing for ULEZ; an older one pays by the day. That daily figure (twelve pounds and change in recent years — TfL moves it) adds up if the zone is entered on workdays. Birmingham, Bristol and other cities run a CAZ with their own cameras and bands; Glasgow's LEZ is the Scottish cousin. The congestion charge is a different animal: a zone charge in central London, not an emissions test, and a compliant EV can fall in scope once clean-vehicle discounts tighten or lapse.

annual zone cost = chargeable days × daily charge

This form has no ULEZ line. If one car is charged and the other is not, the annual total is folded into “servicing” as a fudge, or added after the result. A non-compliant diesel used five days a week in Greater London can lose a TCO comparison on camera charges alone. A compliant petrol, or any EV that meets the standard, does not. The number plate is checked on the official checker. Forums are not the checker.

All the same, a clean-air badge is not a financial argument. It is a constraint on use. Outside the cameras, it can be ignored. If the round crosses the zone every morning, it may be the real reason for the purchase — and then TCO is a second criterion.

The wallbox that never lands in the TCO

Home pence per kWh assume a place to plug in. A wallbox is how most driveways do that. A straightforward 7 kW install on a modern consumer unit runs £800–£1,500, kit and labour in. A long cable run, a consumer-unit upgrade, an earth rod, or a three-phase supply is another conversation — and another invoice.

The old OZEV domestic grant has closed for most households. That capex is a first-year cost (or a financed one), and this form does not have a box for it. Spread over the years the car will be kept, or added to the EV purchase price, if the TCO is to notice.

wallbox in TCO ≈ install cost ÷ years kept

Without off-street parking there is no wallbox to spread. Public charging then is not a convenience; it is the energy line. A house that already has a charger types 0 for install and keeps the cheap unit rate. A simulation at 20 p/kWh that forgets the box compares a socket that is not there yet with a petrol pump that already is. In short, for a first EV and a five-year hold, the install is a real down-payment, not a footnote.

Vehicle Excise Duty on both columns

VED is the annual tax disc in all but name. The form does not invent a band. Zero-emission cars now pay first-year VED and then the standard rate; the old EV exemption has gone. Petrol and diesel first-year rates follow CO2, so a hot petrol hatch can hurt in year one more than a small diesel. The expensive-car supplement (list price above a published threshold, historically £40,000) has been pulling EVs in because so many of them sit above that line. Bands and thresholds move at Budgets — this year's letters from GOV.UK, not a memory of 2019 when EVs were “free to tax”.

Five or ten years of VED can be added into the servicing box if it is wanted inside the TCO, or kept as a mental extra. An EV that lost its exemption and an ICE that sits in a high first-year band are not “the same tax”. Diesel is not automatically dearer than petrol on VED; CO2 and list price do the work. VED rarely flips a close comparison — ULEZ and energy shout louder — but leaving it at zero on both sides is at least fair, while leaving it at zero on the ICE and imagining the EV is exempt is not.

Glossary

TCO
Total cost of ownership: everything the car costs between purchase and resale (energy, servicing, insurance, interest, minus what the car fetches), not just the sticker price.
Depreciation
The year-on-year loss of value, entered here as a compounded annual percentage. At 20% a year, 80% of the price remains after one year, 64% after two, and so on.
PCP
Personal Contract Purchase: a monthly finance deal with a guaranteed minimum future value and an optional balloon at the end. Not a repayment loan, and not the shape of deal this page models.
HP
Hire purchase: a repayment loan secured on the car. Closer to the optional credit tick-box on this form than PCP or contract hire.
BIK
Benefit in Kind: the taxable value, for the employee, of a company car. Charged as a percentage of the P11D list price, with a much lower percentage for most pure EVs than for petrol or diesel.
P11D
The list price HMRC uses for company-car tax, including VAT and factory options, not the discounted price actually paid. BIK is a percentage of this figure.
kWh
Kilowatt-hour: the unit of electrical energy on the bill. One kWh is a thousand watts for an hour — roughly a 1 kW heater for an hour, or a compact EV for about four miles.
VED
Vehicle Excise Duty, still called road tax in everyday speech: the annual (and first-year) charge based on CO2 and, for some cars, list price. The old EV exemption has gone.
WLTP
Worldwide Harmonised Light Vehicle Test Procedure: the lab cycle behind catalogue range and consumption. Useful for comparing two window stickers; misleading once winter, a motorway or a loaded boot get involved.
SOH
State of health of the traction battery: remaining capacity against new. 90% at 40,000 miles is ageing, not a fault. Maker warranties often trigger below about 70%.
OZEV
Office for Zero Emission Vehicles: the UK body that used to run plug-in car grants and domestic chargepoint support. Most of those schemes have closed for ordinary cars and households.
ULEZ
Ultra Low Emission Zone: London's camera-enforced daily charge for vehicles that do not meet the published Euro standard. Other UK cities run Clean Air Zones with their own bands.
AMAP
Approved Mileage Allowance Payments: HMRC's published pence-per-mile scale for reimbursing an employee who uses a private car for work. It is not a true TCO.