Compare Electricity Tariffs From Different Suppliers
Two electricity tariffs rarely land on the same yearly total: it comes down to the price per kWh, the standing charge, and — for a time-of-use plan — how the household's consumption splits between day and night, or peak and off-peak. The form takes a yearly consumption, that split, then the tariffs to compare. Any supplier can be entered: the rates on the tariff information label are enough.
Consumption, split and tariffs
An asterisk after a tariff term points to its entry in the glossary at the end of the article.
Economy 7 and Economy 10: a day/night split without a smart meter
Economy 7* is seven cheap hours, usually somewhere overnight. The window is not national. The distribution network operator decides it — 00:30 to 07:30 in one postcode, 23:00 to 06:00 in the next, sometimes a radio teleswitch that drifts. Economy 10 stretches to ten hours, often split: a night block plus a mid-afternoon sliver. The bill, or the old analogue meter’s two registers, is the only honest source if no smart meter is fitted.
A typical household that does not heat with electricity, and does not charge a car, might put 25% to 35% of its units on the night rate. That is the 70/30 preset on this page. Storage heaters change the picture completely: they are designed to drink the cheap window, and 50% or 60% off-peak is not unusual. A flat that cooks at 6 pm and watches television until midnight, with no timer on anything, can easily sit at 15% night rate. Then Economy 7 is just a higher day unit rate plus a standing charge that did not get cheaper.
Without a smart meter, both registers can be read on the same weekday, then again a week later. Night kWh over the week, divided by total kWh, is the split. Rough, but usable. Inventing 50/50 because it “looks fair” will pick the wrong tariff more reliably than a slightly wrong 75/25.
- Immersion heater on a timer — often 800 to 1,200 kWh a year, almost all night rate if the cylinder is wired through the off-peak contactor.
- Nothing on a timer — start near 80/20. Those seven hours are when the house is asleep.
- Washer and dishwasher delayed — perhaps 5 to 10 points clawed back. Not a new lifestyle.
Time-of-use tariffs (Agile, Cosy and similar)
Octopus Agile publishes a new price for every half-hour, the day before, tied to wholesale. Cosy Octopus is tamer: three cheap windows aimed at heat pumps, a dearer evening peak, a middling rate the rest of the time. Other suppliers have “Go” overnight rates for EVs, or a plunging Sunday afternoon. Different brand names. Same arithmetic this form already does — more slots, more prices.
Agile cannot be typed in as six fixed prices. It has forty-eight. The honest workaround is to bucket a year of half-hourly use into a few bands (evening peak, daytime, overnight, maybe a “plunge” band if those are chased) and put an average unit rate on each. Ugly. Closer to the bill than pretending Agile is a 70/30 Economy 7.
Who it suits: a household that can move a car charge, a heat pump, a tank of water. Who it burns: a household whose load is the kettle, the hob and the 6 pm radiator, with nobody watching the app. A few cheap dunks a year do not pay for a winter of peak-rate heating.
The peak / standard / off-peak preset (30 / 45 / 25) is a sketch of a time-of-use year, not a forecast of Agile. A cold January with the heat pump running through the evening peak will not look like that split. Re-run the numbers after a season of data, not after reading a forum post.
Half-hourly smart-meter data and the split on the form
A SMETS2 meter can record every thirty minutes. Whether that record is visible depends on the consent given and on the supplier’s app. Octopus, OVO and some others surface it. The Bright app, n3rgy, and the Midata route are the usual workarounds when the supplier’s own portal is stingy.
Export a year. Sum the kWh that fall inside the cheap window, the kWh that do not. For a three-rate Cosy-style deal, three sums. Those percentages are what this form wants. A month of data is better than a guess; a winter-plus-summer pair is better than a month, because January is not July.
If the meter remains in “dummy” mode, or the communications WAN is down (a known rural pain), only a monthly total arrives. Fine for a single-rate comparison. Useless for Economy 7. Get the WAN healthy before a night-rate percentage is trusted.
Standing charge, MPAN and supply capacity
The standing charge* is a daily fee, billed whether a unit is used or not. It pays for pipes-and-wires, metering, some policy levies. It varies by region more than most people expect — London is not the South West, Scotland is not either of them. Two “same” tariffs from one supplier can differ by 10 or 15 cents a day before a kettle has boiled.
Domestic supply capacity is usually just the fuse in the cut-out, 60, 80 or 100 amps. That fuse is almost never shopped for when switching. What is shopped for is the standing charge that happens to sit on that MPAN*. Enter the annualised standing charge from the tariff information label, not a national average cribbed from a newspaper.
A low-use flat (a couple of thousand kWh) can lose a cheap unit rate to a fat standing charge. A high-use house barely notices the standing charge and lives or dies on the unit rate. This page adds both. Leave neither blank.
Yearly cost = standing charge (region, MPAN) + Σ (slot kWh × slot unit rate)
Same average p/kWh, different annual cost
Comparison sites love a single number. 24p a unit, in a big typeface. That average was built on Ofgem’s “typical” household — medium TDCV*, a particular split, often no storage heating. The household filling this form is not that household.
Take the two defaults on this form. A flat 0.24 everywhere, standing charge 130. Against 0.26 day / 0.16 night, standing charge 140. At 70/30 and 3,100 kWh the Economy 7 often wins. At 90/10 it loses. The brochure’s “average unit rate” did not move. The split did.
There is no average kWh until whose year it is has been said. That is the whole point of typing the percentages in.
Ofgem price cap versus a fixed deal
The price cap* is a ceiling on the default tariff — the standard variable, the one a household sits on if it never chooses. It is not a promise that every deal in the market sits under it. Fixed tariffs can be cheaper than the cap, or dearer, depending on where wholesale prices have gone since the fix was priced.
What never changes when the supplier changes: the wires. The DNO. The meter. VAT at 5% on domestic electricity. The quality of the voltage. What does change: the unit rate, the standing charge, whether the contract is a cap-tracking SVT or a fix, and how painful next April will look.
“Below the cap” is not a personality trait. A twelve-month fix signed in a cheap month can look clever until the cap falls under it. Re-run the comparison when the cap is reset (Ofgem does it quarterly) and when the fix is within a couple of months of ending. Once a decade is not a strategy.
Electric heating and EVs: which tariff wins
Ofgem’s medium electricity-only home is around 2,700 to 3,100 kWh a year. Storage heaters, a heat pump, or an EV on the driveway blow through that. 6,000, 8,000, 12,000 kWh, and the unit rate starts to dominate. Two cents on 8,000 kWh is 160. The standing charge hardly twitched.
When the kWh happen matters just as much. Panel heaters peak in the evening, on the dear rate, on Agile’s worst half-hours. An EV on a 7 kW home charger, plugged in at 10 pm, can dump most of its 2,000-odd kWh onto the cheap window. Same extra volume, opposite tariff winner.
A Cosy or an EV “Go” tariff that looks brilliant on a forum will look ordinary if the car lives on a lamp-post and the heating is a 3 kW fan in the living room. Change the yearly kWh, change the split, run it again. The neighbour’s result is not transferable.
The appliance electricity cost page will put a number on a single heater or a charger. This page then asks which slot those kWh fall into. Both questions, in that order.
A house move or new kit before switching
A new tenancy is a new MPAN. The old tariff does not travel. The incoming supplier of last resort will park the meter on a default rate until a deal is picked. Model the next house: a Victorian terrace with storage heaters is not a new-build with a heat pump, even at the same floor area.
Same caution for kit not yet bought. An EV, 2,000 to 4,000 kWh a year depending on mileage, mostly overnight if charging is on the drive. A tumble dryer. A hot tub. Add the volume, decide which slot it lands in, then compare tariffs before locking a twelve-month fix priced for the old life.
EPC ratings and the previous occupant’s bills both lie, in different directions. Run a low case and a high case. One number is a false comfort.
Fixed-deal pitfalls and welcome credits
Fixed usually means the unit rate and standing charge are frozen. Policy costs and VAT can still shuffle, and some “fixes” exclude quite a lot. The tariff information label is the document. The homepage banner is not.
A “£75 welcome credit” is another game. Is it applied on day one, or after twelve months if the customer is still there? Does leaving early claw it back? In this form, type the unit rates that will actually be paid over a rolling year. If the credit is real, knock it off the standing charge (or off the total) once — do not pretend the unit rate is permanently 3p lower.
Exit fees on a fix — often £50 to £75 a fuel — do not appear in this calculator. If a house move or a better deal in month eight is likely, add them by hand. A “saving” of £40 a year against a £75 exit fee is not a saving.
Why a friend in another postcode is not a useful comparison
Great Britain is split into electricity distribution regions. Standing charges and, to a lesser extent, unit rates carry that region’s network costs. A deal that “won” for someone in the East Midlands can lose in the South East before a single kettle is boiled. Always pull the prices for the relevant postcode, from the supplier’s quote or the TIL, not from a screenshot in a Facebook group.
The MPAN itself (the bottom number on the bill, starting 13 or similar) is tied to the property, not to the person. Take it to the quote. It stops the supplier guessing the wrong profile class — Economy 7 versus single-rate is exactly the kind of mix-up that produces a confident, wrong comparison.
Profile class 1 is unrestricted domestic. Profile class 2 is Economy 7. Mixing them on a quote is how a night-rate percentage is applied to a meter that has no night register, or the other way around.
Dual fuel is not a spare electricity discount
Bundling gas and electricity with one supplier is convenient. It is not automatically cheaper on the electricity half. Plenty of “cheap dual-fuel” deals bury a so-so electricity unit rate under a sharp gas price, or the other way around. This page only does electricity. Run it honestly, then look at gas on its own numbers, then add. If the dual-fuel saving is a £20 paper discount against a £60 electricity overshoot, nothing has been saved.
Gas itself is a different unit and a different calorific-value ritual — the oil and gas energy equivalent page is the place for cubic metres into kWh. Do not convert a dual-fuel “saving” into an electricity p/kWh by dividing by the electricity volume. That arithmetic hides the gas half.
Online Direct Debit is usually the cheapest payment method. Prepay and standard credit sit higher, sometimes a lot higher, even under the cap. If the quote assumes Direct Debit and the meter is a key meter, the comparison is of a tariff that will not be the one billed.
The fourteen-day cooling-off, and what happens to the old contract
A switch is a change of contract, not a change of cable. The meter stays. The DNO stays. The old supplier is not phoned to “cancel” — the new one issues the loss. It often takes one to three weeks. There should be no cut-off.
Distance sales come with a fourteen-day cooling-off. Use it if the welcome pack does not match the quote. After that, a fix may carry an exit fee. Keep the opening meter read (or the smart meter’s daily read) on the switch date; it is the only thing that stops a reconciliation bill inventing a month of usage.
Hopping every eight weeks to chase £15 a year is a poor use of a Saturday. An £80 or £100 gap is worth the form. Under that, maybe not.
Glossary
- Economy 7
- A two-rate domestic tariff: a cheaper night window of about seven hours, set by the local network, and a dearer day rate. Economy 10 adds extra off-peak hours, often including a mid-afternoon block. Both need a meter that can record two registers.
- Standing charge
- A daily fee, billed whether any kWh are used or not. It covers network costs, metering and some policy levies, and it varies by electricity distribution region. Enter the annualised figure from the tariff information label.
- MPAN
- Meter Point Administration Number. The supply identifier printed on the bill (often the “bottom number”, starting 13 or similar). It belongs to the property, not to the customer, and it tells the supplier the profile class and the region.
- TDCV
- Typical Domestic Consumption Values, published by Ofgem. The “medium” electricity-only household is around 2,700 to 3,100 kWh/year. Comparison-site averages are built on these figures, not on any one house.
- Ofgem price cap
- A ceiling on the default (standard variable) tariff for a typical household, reset quarterly. It is not a market-wide promise, and a fixed deal can sit above or below it. VAT on domestic electricity remains 5% either way.