Equivalent dynamic load of a bearing (P = X·Fr + Y·Fa)
A bearing often carries two loads at once: a radial load Fr (perpendicular to the axis) and an axial load Fa (along the axis). The life calculation, however, only knows one load. The combination is therefore reduced to a fictitious pure radial load, the equivalent dynamic load P, which would fatigue the bearing just as much as the two loads together.
The X (radial) and Y (axial) factors come from the bearing catalogue: they express how well the bearing carries axial load. For a purely radial load, take X = 1 and Y = 0: P = Fr.
Loads and factors
Bearing terms marked * are set out in the glossary.
Why the life formula wants a single load P
A ball or a roller does not care whether the Hertzian patch came from a pulley pull or from a thrust collar. Fatigue cares about contact intensity, repeated, on the raceway. ISO 281* was written for one load: a purely radial load* on a rotating inner ring. Real machines almost never apply that case. A helical gear throws axial load*. A belt can, if the pulley is not square. A vertical rotor sits on its own weight.
The equivalent dynamic load* P is the device that joins the two worlds. It is a fictitious radial load that would spall the bearing at the same rate as the real mix of Fr and Fa.
P = X × Fr + Y × Fa
P is not a vector sum, and it is not “the bigger of the two”. X and Y* are dimensionless weights taken from the catalogue for that bearing, at that Fa/Fr ratio. With the wrong factors, the L10 rating life that follows is a tidy number with the wrong load inside it. On paper the shaft looks fine. The raceway disagrees a year later.
Where the X and Y factors actually come from
X and Y are not derived at the desk from first principles, not on a Tuesday afternoon.
The manufacturer has already run the contact calculation for each series and printed the result. X is the radial factor; Y is the axial factor. Both depend on the type — deep-groove ball, angular-contact ball, self-aligning ball, spherical roller, tapered roller — and, for most ball bearings, on the ratio of the axial load to the basic static load rating C0.
Why C0, a static figure, inside a fatigue formula? Because Fa/C0 is a convenient stand-in for how hard the contact is being shoved off the groove bottom. A small axial load rides in the deepest part of the race; a large one climbs the shoulder. The Hertzian stress field changes, so Y changes. SKF, Schaeffler, NSK, Timken: they all tabulate the same idea, sometimes against Fa/C0, sometimes against a catalogue factor f0·Fa/C0. Same job.
On a deep-groove row, Y falls as Fa/C0 rises — of the order of 2 down toward 1 — while X sits at 1 below a threshold and then drops to about 0.56 once axial load is no longer a rounding error. Angular-contact and tapered-roller rows are built to take thrust: Y is smaller, and it is printed as a single number per series, not as a staircase against C0.
The calculation factor e: when axial load can be ignored
Every combined-load table has a column e*, the limiting value of Fa/Fr. It is the hinge of the whole method.
- Fa/Fr ≤ e — axial load is treated as negligible. X = 1, Y = 0, so P = Fr. The ratio still has to be checked; the catalogue is not optional.
- Fa/Fr > e — both components count. X drops below 1 (X ≈ 0.56 on a deep-groove ball bearing) and Y comes off the table for that Fa/C0.
e itself is not a constant: on a deep-groove ball bearing it typically runs from about 0.2 at a light axial load up toward 0.4 when Fa/C0 is large. On a 40° angular-contact ball bearing e is already above 1: the contact angle is doing the work, so a “mostly axial” load is normal, not a special case. Fa/Fr is compared with the e on that line of the table, not with a number remembered from a 6204.
A common miss is to treat a small Fa as Y = 0 and stop. Small against Fr is not the test. Small against e is. A 1 kN thrust on a 3 kN radial load is already Fa/Fr = 0.33, which sits above e for many deep-groove sizes. Y at that point is often 1.4 to 1.8, so the axial term can outweigh the radial one inside P.
Typical X and Y values for catalogue bearings
The form on this page defaults to X = 0.56 and Y = 1.5 because that is the everyday deep-groove case once e has been crossed. It is a starting point, not a universal constant.
- Purely radial load — pulley, spur gear, a rotor with no thrust bearing duty. X = 1, Y = 0. P = Fr. When Fa really is zero, a decorative Y does not belong in the sum.
- Deep-groove ball bearing with some axial load — beyond e, X ≈ 0.56 and Y of the order of 1 to 2, falling as Fa/C0 rises. At Fa/C0 ≈ 0.1, Y is often near 1.5, which is why that number sits in the form.
- Angular-contact ball bearing or tapered roller bearing — designed for thrust. Y is given directly for the series (and for the contact angle: 15°, 25°, 40° on balls; the cup angle on a taper). They are often mounted in pairs so that axial load can be taken both ways.
- Cylindrical roller, NU or N — no ribs, no axial capacity worth talking about. P = Fr, and any thrust has to go somewhere else. NJ, NUP and similar ribbed types take a limited axial load; the catalogue says how much, and it is not a deep-groove Y.
With the defaults in the form: Fr = 4 kN, Fa = 2 kN, X = 0.56, Y = 1.5.
P = 0.56 × 4 + 1.5 × 2 = 2.24 + 3.0 = 5.24 kN
The axial term is more than half of P, and Fa is only half of Fr. That is the whole point of Y. The same 4 kN on a pure radial duty gives P = 4 kN — on the life formula the bearing is more lightly loaded, because it is doing less work. A helical pinion never offers that simplification.
Dynamic P is not static P0
Two formulas, same shape, different job, different factors. Mixing them is the classic catalogue howler.
P = X·Fr + Y·Fa (ISO 281, fatigue) ; P0 = X0·Fr + Y0·Fa (ISO 76, indentation)
P feeds the rating-life calculation while the bearing turns. P0 feeds the static safety factor s0 while the bearing is at rest or barely creeping, so that a ball or roller does not dent the raceway. For a deep-groove ball bearing the static pair is often X0 = 0.6 and Y0 = 0.5 — not 0.56 and 1.5. A peak with the shaft locked is a P0 problem even if the running P looks gentle: a press push, a crane that has just picked up, a cold start with a seized coupling.
P does not go into s0 = C0/P0, and P0 does not go into L10 = (C/P)p. C and C0 are two catalogue columns. X, Y and X0, Y0 are two tables. Four numbers, two checks, both required.
How to read X and Y off an SKF or Schaeffler page
The product page that matters is the size going into the housing — not a “typical 6200” carried over from memory. Three figures are required before this calculator is of any use: C (basic dynamic load rating), C0 (basic static load rating), and the combined-load table for that series.
- Fr and Fa are converted to the same unit as C0 (catalogue kN, usually).
- Fa/C0 is formed. Where the table is written in f0·Fa/C0, f0 is read from the same page — it is a bearing factor, not a load — and multiplied in.
- e and Y are read on that row, with interpolation where the ratio falls between lines. Linear interpolation is what the handbooks expect.
- Fa/Fr is formed. At or below e, X = 1 and Y = 0. Above e, X is taken from the “Fa/Fr > e” column (0.56 on a single-row deep-groove) and Y is the value just interpolated.
- P is computed here; P and C are then carried to the life page. C never enters P; it enters L10.
A 6208 with C0 ≈ 19 kN, Fr = 4 kN and Fa = 2 kN gives Fa/C0 ≈ 0.11. On a deep-groove table that lands near e ≈ 0.3 and Y ≈ 1.5. Fa/Fr = 0.5, which is above e, so X = 0.56. That is the worked example above, not a coincidence: the defaults on this page are a 6208-shaped duty. A 6308 on the same loads would use a different C0 and a slightly different Y. The size is not a spectator.
Timken writes tapered-roller factors as K (or Y) on the series drawing, not as a staircase against C0. Schaeffler’s media library and SKF’s product tables are both sound sources. An SKF X does not belong with a Timken Y from a neighbouring size merely because the two figures look similar.
X and O arrangements: who takes the thrust
A single-row angular-contact ball bearing, or a single-row tapered roller, takes thrust in one direction. The other direction has to go to a second bearing. The orientation of the contact lines changes both the stiffness and the X, Y the catalogue allows for the pair.
- O arrangement, back-to-back (DB) — contact lines diverge, wide effective span. Takes a moment. Shaft growth on heat tends to unload the preload. Machine-tool spindles live here.
- X arrangement, face-to-face (DF) — contact lines converge, narrower span. More forgiving of misalignment, less happy with a moment. Shaft growth tends to tighten the preload: the housing had better be able to take that.
- Tandem (DT) — both rows look the same way. Axial capacity in one direction roughly doubles; the other direction needs a third bearing or a different type.
The pair is then treated as one unit: the catalogue prints a second set of X and Y, often with a different e, under “two bearings arranged DB or DF”. Two single-row P values are not added. Fr and Fa are taken on the pair, the paired table is read, and one P is computed for the set. Universal-face bearings (SU, DU) can be stacked either way. A matched pair with a ground spacer already knows its preload. Left to itself, a random pair of “the same 7208” off the shelf is not a matched set.
For life, a back-to-back pair under a moment is not two equal shares. The more heavily loaded row sets P. When the moment cannot be split, the conservative P is taken on one row and is not averaged with the idle one.
Induced axial load on a single-row tapered roller
A tapered roller under a pure radial load generates an induced axial force, because the race is a cone.
Fa, induced ≈ Fr / (2Y)
The cup tries to squeeze the cone out, so that thrust has to be caught by the opposing bearing, a rib or a housing shoulder — without that reaction the sum contains a load the drawing never showed. Y in the formula is the axial factor of that tapered row, from the series table. With two tapers in opposition, the induced force of each row is compared with any external Fa, and the net axial load on the more heavily loaded bearing is what goes into P. The lightly loaded row may unload. A “purely radial” gearbox shaft on two 32208s is never purely radial at the raceway.
Angular-contact singles do the same thing, milder, in proportion to the contact angle. A 15° row induces less than a 40° row for the same Fr. The locating bearing of a motor with a helical pinion has to swallow both the gear thrust and the induced component. A mental sum is how a 7205 ends up doing a 7207’s job.
Needle and cylindrical rows with no ribs do not induce this force, and they cannot take it. The axial path is a different component — a deep-groove, an angular-contact or a thrust washer — so P on the roller row stays Fr, while P on the thrust row is its own calculation, often with Fr = 0, X = 0, Y = 1, so P = Fa.
What to do with P once it is known
P is an intermediate. It does not say whether the bearing is big enough. Three sister checks follow, in this order, and none of them is optional because another one “looked fine”.
- Equivalent dynamic load P — this page. Combined Fr and Fa, catalogue X and Y.
- Basic rating life L10 — P and the basic dynamic load rating C go to the rating life calculator (ISO 281). That is hours and millions of revolutions, not a pass/fail on load.
- Static safety s0 — P0 is formed with X0 and Y0 (or the worst standing peak is used) and set against C0 on the static safety page (ISO 76). Slow, shocked, or parked under load: this one decides, not L10.
Variable load is a fourth step, not a different formula. A duty cycle of several (Fr, Fa, n, time) slices needs a cubic mean P for ball bearings (or a 10/3 mean for rollers) before that mean is fed into L10. One P taken at the “typical” load does not carry the duty. A press that idles at 2 kN and hits 18 kN for two seconds in ten still dies on the peak. A clean constant-speed fan may stay as simple as this form.
Fr, Fa, C and C0 stay in the same unit wherever they are combined. The calculator converts; a spreadsheet at 2 a.m. does not. Newtons and kilonewtons mixed inside X·Fr + Y·Fa produce a P that looks plausible and is out by a factor of a thousand. The place to catch that is the top of the sheet, before the housing is bored.
Glossary
- Equivalent load
- The equivalent dynamic load P is the constant radial load which, applied to a bearing with a rotating inner ring, would give the same rating life as the actual combination of radial and axial load. ISO 281 writes it as P = X·Fr + Y·Fa. It is not a vector sum of the two components, and it is not the static equivalent load P0.
- Radial load
- The component Fr of the bearing load acting at right angles to the shaft axis. Pulley pull and a spur-gear mesh are ordinary radial loads. When there is no axial component, or when Fa/Fr is at or below the threshold e, P reduces to Fr.
- Axial load
- The component Fa of the bearing load acting along the shaft axis. Catalogue tables often call it thrust. A helical gear, a belt pulley that is not square, and the weight of a vertical rotor are ordinary sources. In the combined-load table, Fa drops out of P when Fa/Fr is at or below e, and is weighted by Y when the ratio lies above e.
- Factors X and Y
- Dimensionless catalogue factors in the ISO 281 expression for P. X weights the radial load; Y weights the axial load. They belong to one bearing type and, for most ball bearings, to one row of the Fa/C0 table. They are not the static factors X0 and Y0 from ISO 76.
- ISO 281
- The international standard for dynamic load ratings and rating life of rolling bearings. It defines the basic dynamic load rating C, the basic rating life L10, and the equivalent dynamic load P that enters the life equation. The reference case in the standard is a purely radial load on a rotating inner ring.
- Threshold e
- The limiting value of Fa/Fr in the combined-load table, also called the calculation factor e. At or below e, axial load is left out of P (X = 1, Y = 0). Above e, both components count and X and Y are read from that same row. e depends on bearing type and, on a deep-groove ball bearing, on Fa/C0.