EN

Motor Replacement Energy Savings & Payback Calculator

A single point of efficiency can be worth hundreds of euros a year on a motor that runs several thousand hours — the gap between an old motor (often IE1 or IE2) and a recent high-efficiency model (IE3, IE4) adds up quickly. This calculator estimates the annual energy saving and the time it takes for that saving to pay back the replacement investment.

A local energy-efficiency grant or incentive scheme may reduce the net investment for replacing an industrial motor with a high-efficiency model where you are — enter the amount if you know it, otherwise leave it at 0. Schemes and amounts vary widely by country, so none is assumed here.

The current motor and its replacement

Operating point
Efficiency

Rough IE1/IE2 figure for an older motor of this size — check the nameplate.

Rough IE3 figure for this power range.

Investment

Result

The replacement saves 451 €/year (3,008 kWh/year), for a net investment of 2,400 € — paid back in 63.8 months.

  • Annual saving 451 €
  • Annual saving 3,008 kWh
  • Payback period 63.8 months
  • Net gain over 10 years 2,112 €
Annual consumption — current motor51,136 kWh
Annual consumption — replacement motor48,128 kWh
Annual saving3,008 kWh (451 €)
Net investment (purchase price − grant)2,400 €
Payback period63.8 months
Net cumulative gain over 10 years2,112 €

The calculation, in detail

Annual consumption = Power × Load factor × Hours ÷ Efficiency

Payback (months) = (Purchase price − Grant) ÷ Annual saving × 12

Local energy-efficiency grants and incentive schemes: how they typically work

The grant field on this form is optional and defaults to zero. That is deliberate. Schemes change by country, by year, and by who signs the invoice. What they share is a shape: a public body or a utility pays part of the extra cost of a higher-efficiency motor, so the payback shortens.

Typical patterns, not a shopping list:

  • A rebate per kilowatt of rated output if you jump at least one IE class.
  • A white-certificate or supplier-obligation credit, often cashed in by the installer rather than by you.
  • An accelerated tax write-off instead of cash.

Some programmes want the old motor scrapped so it cannot be resold into a grey market. Some want a measurement plan. None of them should be typed in as a round number you hoped for — use the offer you actually have, or leave the field at 0 and treat the payback as the unsubsidised worst case.

Well, a grant of €400 on a €2,400 motor is a 17 % haircut on the investment. It does not change the kWh saving. It only changes how long you wait to be whole.

Repair or replace a failed motor? Rewinding usually degrades efficiency

When a motor dies, the quote for a rewind looks cheap next to a new IE3 or IE4. The rewind puts the machine back on the shaft. It does not put it back on the nameplate. Stator copper is rarely restored to the original packing factor; slot insulation gets a bit thicker; a careless burn-out of the old winding can damage the laminations and raise iron losses. A good shop on a large machine can hold the efficiency to within a point. A cheap rewind on a small aluminium-frame motor can drop it by two or three.

That drop is permanent, and it runs every hour until the next failure. A 15 kW motor at 4,000 h/year, 75 % load, going from 92 % to 90 %: you just bought yourself roughly 1,100 kWh/year of extra heat. At €0.15/kWh that is €165 a year — which is how a “cheap” rewind pays for a new motor without anyone noticing. If the failed machine was already IE1, the case for replacement is even louder: you were going to buy copper anyway.

A rewind still makes sense on a special-purpose machine (odd shaft, odd voltage, no stock frame) or a very large rating where the stator is a capital item. For a catalogue IEC motor below a few tens of kilowatts, running thousands of hours, replacement is usually the cheaper five-year decision.

Depreciating the new motor: link to the depreciation schedule calculator

Energy payback is cash. Accounting is a different ledger. The new motor is a fixed asset: you write it down over its useful life, and the annual depreciation hits the P&L whether or not the kWh saving showed up this month. Straight-line over ten years on a €2,400 purchase is €240/year — which may be more or less than the energy saving, depending on the hours.

Tax rules (declining balance, first-year allowances, energy-saving plant pools) are local. This page does not apply them. If you need the year-by-year book value, use the depreciation schedule calculator and keep the two stories apart: one is “when does the electricity pay me back”, the other is “what does the accountant book”. Mixing them produces a payback that no one in the plant will recognise.

Avoided carbon footprint, beyond the financial saving alone

Every kilowatt-hour you stop drawing has a carbon number attached. That number is the grid factor where the motor sits, not a universal constant. A rough UK or EU order of magnitude is 0.2 to 0.4 kg CO2e per kWh — falling as the mix decarbonises, higher if the site is on a coal-heavy grid or a diesel generator. A 5,000 kWh/year saving is then one to two tonnes of CO2e per year. Not a climate plan on its own. Not nothing either, if you have a hundred motors.

The calculator stays in euros because the form would lie if it picked a carbon factor for you. Multiply the kWh saving by your site's published factor if you need a Scope 2 line. Do not double-count if the tariff already includes a carbon price.

Oversized motors: sometimes the real saving is right-sizing, not a like-for-like replacement

The form assumes the same rated kW on both machines. That is the honest comparison of two efficiencies. It is not always the honest comparison of two plants. A 15 kW motor on a 7 kW load spends its life on the wrong part of the efficiency curve, at a poor power factor, paying iron losses for a rating nobody uses. Replacing it with a 15 kW IE4 is a small win. Replacing it with a 7.5 or 11 kW IE3, correctly loaded, is often a bigger one.

Right-sizing needs a measured load — a logger on the current, not a guess from the nameplate of the pump. Starting torque still has to be enough; a star-delta start or a VFD can cover a smaller motor that would stall DOL. If you do right-size, run this calculator with the new rated power and a load factor nearer 80–100 %, not 40 %. The payback will look different, because it is a different project.

What one efficiency point is worth

The saving is not “the new motor uses 5.5 points less, so 5.5 % of the bill”. Input power is Pshaft / η. Going from 88 % to 93.5 % on a 15 kW shaft at 75 % load is:

ΔE = P · load · hours · (1/ηold − 1/ηnew)

That is about 800 kWh per 1,000 hours, in the default example. At 4,000 h and €0.15/kWh, a few hundred euros a year. One point of efficiency is worth more on a big motor than on a small one, and more at 8,000 h than at 800. The hours field is doing more work than the IE badge.

Load factor is the silent input

A motor that is “15 kW” on the plate and 50 % loaded draws energy as a 7.5 kW shaft, not as 15. Type 100 % load factor on a machine that loafs and you will promise a payback the meter will never deliver. Type 50 % on a compressor that actually cycles between 70 and 100 and you will undersell the project. In fact the average load factor is already a compromise: a duty cycle with long idle periods and short peaks is not the same kWh as a flat 75 %.

If you have an energy meter on the feeder, use last year's kWh as a check. Annual consumption on this page should sit in the same neighbourhood. If it does not, the load factor or the hours are wrong — not the efficiency of the new motor.

When replacement does not pay

Low hours, already-decent efficiency, a motor you cannot buy off the shelf, a grant of zero and a cheap tariff: the payback walks out past the remaining life and the project is a feeling, not a number. There is no shame in that result. It is what the form is for.

Anyway, do not force a replacement to “standardise on IE4” if the machine runs two hours a week. Spend the money on the 6,000 h/year pumps first. The cumulative-gain line over the remaining life is the one that tells you whether this particular shaft is in that list.

Related calculators