EN

Calculate the Optical Power of a Lens Doublet

Two thin lenses lined up on the same axis behave as one equivalent system whose optical power depends on how far apart they sit. The optical power page covers lenses in contact (P = P₁ + P₂). Here, work out the power of two spaced lenses (Gullstrand's equation), or the magnification of an afocal system — a telescope.

A system is afocal when a parallel beam going in comes out parallel too: that is how a telescope works (objective + eyepiece), where the separation is exactly e = f₁ + f₂.

L₁L₂e

Inputs

Mode and unit

Switch mode, then run the calculation again to update the fields.

Two spaced lenses (Gullstrand)

Fills in P₁, P₂ (dioptres) and e (cm) — it does not affect the calculation itself.

Distance between the two lenses.

Result

  • Equivalent optical power P 1.600 δ
Lens 1: P₁ 2.000 δ
Lens 2: P₂ -0.500 δ
Separation e 10.00 cm (0.1000 m)
Equivalent optical power P 1.600 δ
Equivalent focal length f = 1/P 62.50 cm (0.6250 m)
Vs. lenses in contact (P₁+P₂, uncorrected) 1.500 δ (6.67% off)

P = P₁ + P₂ − e·P₁·P₂ (Gullstrand, e in metres)

Why the separation changes the equivalent power

Allvar Gullstrand did not invent the air gap to annoy anyone. He needed a formula that still worked when the cornea and the crystalline lens refused to sit in the same plane. The Nobel in 1911 was for a schematic eye. The leftover is the line this calculator uses.

P = P₁ + P₂ − e · P₁ · P₂ (e in metres, P in dioptres)

The second lens does not see the world the first lens saw. Light has already started to converge (or spread) in the gap, so the second element is working on a virtual object that is no longer at infinity, even when the incoming beam was parallel. That mismatch is the extra term. Drop e to zero and it vanishes; leave a centimetre and it starts to matter.

Two +5 dpt lenses 4 cm apart are not +10 dpt. They are 5 + 5 − 0.04 × 5 × 5 = 10 − 1 = 9 dpt. A 10 % hit, from a gap you could hide under a thumb. Spectacle lenses do the same trick in front of the cornea: twelve millimetres of air, and the number on the lens is not quite the power at the eye.

Recovering the lenses-in-contact case (e = 0)

Set the gap to nothing. Gullstrand collapses to P = P₁ + P₂, which is the whole of the optical power page. Same physics, one term fewer.

e = 0 → P = P₁ + P₂

That is why the two tools sit next to each other. In contact, add the dioptres. Spaced apart, keep the product term. Type e = 0 in this calculator and you should land on the raw sum. If you do not, the unit on e has slipped — centimetres left in a formula that wants metres.

So e = 0 is not a different model. It is this one, with the correction switched off.

The afocal condition e = f₁ + f₂

Afocal means the system as a whole has no power. Parallel in, parallel out. Infinite focal length, P = 0. A telescope focused on a distant object is built to do exactly that.

The spacing that kills P is not a round number you guess. Put e = f₁ + f₂ into Gullstrand, with P = 1/f:

P = 1/f₁ + 1/f₂ − (f₁ + f₂) / (f₁ · f₂) = 0

It cancels on the page. What it means on the bench: the intermediate image the objective forms in its back focal plane sits in the front focal plane of the eyepiece. The eyepiece recollimates. No net power left. What is left is a change of angle — the magnification.

Rack the tube a millimetre either way and P is no longer zero. The image of infinity lands a little short of infinity, or a little past it. That is “focusing” a telescope: a controlled leak from the afocal condition, so an eye that is not emmetropic can still take the beam.

Astronomical vs. Galilean telescope

Same tube, two recipes, and the sign of f₂ is the whole difference.

  • Astronomical (Keplerian) — two converging lenses. Long objective, short eyepiece, both f positive. G = −f₁/f₂ comes out negative: the image is inverted. Fine for a star. Awkward for a street. Binoculars add Porro or roof prisms to turn it back.
  • Galilean — converging objective, diverging eyepiece (f₂ < 0). The foci still coincide, but they meet in front of the eyepiece, not between the two glasses. G is positive: image erect. And e = f₁ + f₂ is shorter than f₁, because f₂ is negative. Short tube.

That is why Galileo could hold his instrument, and why opera glasses fit in a bag. The calculator labels it for you: both focal lengths positive → inverted Keplerian; f₁ positive, f₂ negative → erect Galilean. Objective negative, eyepiece positive exists on paper. You will not find it in a shop telescope.

Angular magnification vs. linear (transverse) magnification

Transverse magnification γ = −dᵢ/dₒ is a ratio of heights. It needs an object at a finite distance and an image you can put a ruler on.

A telescope does not offer that. The object is at infinity — the Moon, a ship, the back of the stalls. The final image is at infinity as well; that is what afocal means. There is no image height on a screen. What grows is the angle at the eye.

G = −f₁ / f₂

G = −20× is not “twenty times larger on a ground glass”. It is “the angle at the eye is twenty times wider”. The Moon is about 0.5° naked-eye; at 20× it is 10°. It fills the field. It is not twenty millimetres across on a desk.

Confusing the two is how you end up taping a card behind a telescope and wondering why nothing will focus. Of course it will not: the image is not there. It is at infinity. A real image wants a different use of the eyepiece, or a camera at the objective focus — not an afocal pair.

Worked example: sizing a pocket Galilean (opera glasses)

Wanted: 3×, erect, a tube that disappears into a coat. So Galilean: f₂ negative.

Take f₁ = 120 mm (objective +8.33 dpt) and f₂ = −40 mm (eyepiece −25 dpt).

e = f₁ + f₂ = 120 − 40 = 80 mm

G = −f₁ / f₂ = −(120) / (−40) = +3

Check Gullstrand, e = 0.080 m:

P = 8.33 + (−25) − 0.080 × 8.33 × (−25) ≈ −16.67 + 16.67 = 0

Afocal, 8 cm of tube, 3×, erect. That is an opera glass. The form's Galilean preset is greedier (P₁ = 2 dpt, P₂ = −20 dpt, e = 45 cm, G = 10×): a spyglass, not something you take to Covent Garden.

Limits of the model

Thin lenses. Each element is a plane. Rays stay paraxial (Gaussian optics). No thickness, no glass that changes with colour, no stop.

Aperture — the diameter — never enters Gullstrand. It sets how much light you collect and how fine a double star you can split, not the equivalent power. Field of view is missing too: Galilean telescopes have a tight field, everyone who has used one knows it, and G says nothing about it. A real eyepiece is a cluster of lenses, an eye cup, sometimes a reticle. Here it is a single f₂.

Once the lenses are thick, you need principal planes, and e is the gap between those planes, not between the glass faces. This page stays on two thin elements and a distance.

In Gullstrand, e is in metres if P is in dioptres. Writing “10” on paper and meaning centimetres is a 10 m gap. The product term blows up. The calculator converts from the unit you picked; a scrap of paper does not.

Opera glasses in a bag

Whether they fit in a bag is not a question about G. It is a question about e. Keplerian, e = f₁ + f₂, both positive: a 3× with a 120 mm objective already wants 160 mm of tube before you add eyecups. Galilean, e = f₁ − |f₂|: the same 3× (120 mm and −40 mm) sits in 80 mm. That is the entire trick of opera glasses.

No prisms. None needed — the image is already the right way up. Less glass, less weight, less length. The bill comes due in the dark of the stalls: a narrow field, a vignette that closes in, and anything past 4× starts to feel like a toy you are fighting. 2.5× or 3× is the deal. Enough to read a surtitle. Not enough to aim at Jupiter.

A 3× Keplerian with Porro prisms is a “proper” binocular: heavier, dearer, and it no longer slides into a clutch. Opera glasses are optically modest on purpose. That is the point of the bag, not a defect in the glass.

Kepler vs Galilean at A-level

Most A-level labs start with Kepler, and not because it is kinder. The drawer is full of converging lenses — +10 cm, +20 cm, a ray box, a window as the distant object. Two positives, e = f₁ + f₂, inverted image of the trees outside, and the sign of G is something you can see. You read −f₁/f₂ and check that the world really is upside down.

Galilean wants a diverging lens. Plenty of sixth-form cupboards have one, cracked, or none. And an erect image looks, to a tired class, like “it isn't doing anything, it just looks a bit bigger”. Miss the afocal spacing by a centimetre and P is no longer zero; the eye accommodates, the measurement wanders, and someone writes that Galilean “doesn't work”.

If you can pick, do Kepler first: f₁ = 150 mm, f₂ = 30 mm, e = 180 mm, G = −5. The inverted image is a loud signal that the system is a system. Then Galilean, f₁ = 120 mm, f₂ = −40 mm, e = 80 mm. Same order of G, erect, shorter tube. The algebra does not change. The practical often shows only one of them.

Related calculators