Induction vs Permanent-Magnet Synchronous Motor Cost Comparison
Permanent-magnet synchronous motors are gaining ground thanks to higher efficiency, especially at variable speed — but they usually cost more to buy than an induction motor of the same power. Induction motors remain the reference for high power ratings and harsh environments, at a lower purchase cost. Comparing the two on purchase price alone, or on the electricity bill alone, gives an incomplete picture: it's the total cost over the operating life — purchase, energy, maintenance — that supports an informed choice for a given application.
Fill in both columns below with each motor's characteristics for the same power rating and operating point.
The two motors to compare
Result
Over 10 years at 4,000 h/year, PM synchronous motor costs 2,132 € less than Induction motor.
- Total cost — PM synchronous motor 74,148 €
- Total cost — Induction motor 76,281 €
- Annual energy — synchronous 46,632 kWh
- Annual energy — induction 48,387 kWh
| PM synchronous motor | Induction motor | Gap (sync. − induction) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | 3,200 € | 2,200 € | 1,000 € |
| Energy, 10 years | 69,948 € | 72,581 € | -2,632 € |
| Maintenance, 10 years | 1,000 € | 1,500 € | -500 € |
| Total cost | 74,148 € | 76,281 € | -2,132 € |
| Average annual cost | 7,415 € | 7,628 € | — |
Running-hours break-even point. Below 760 h/year, Induction motor stays cheaper; above it, PM synchronous motor becomes cheaper. That's the synchronous motor's break-even point in this simulation.
The calculation, in detail
Total cost = Purchase + (Annual energy cost + Maintenance) × Operating life
Annual energy cost = Power × Load factor × Hours ÷ Efficiency × Electricity price
IE1 to IE5 efficiency classes: what they actually mean by power band
An IE class is not a round number you pick off a brochure. IEC 60034-30-1 sets a minimum full-load efficiency for each combination of rated output and pole count. A 15 kW four-pole motor and a 1.1 kW two-pole motor can both be “IE3” while sitting several points of efficiency apart. The class is a band, not a single percentage.
- IE1 — standard. Still turning on old plant. Cheap to buy, expensive to run if the hours are high.
- IE2 — high efficiency. The floor that used to be the legal minimum in Europe; now the leftover stock and the small ratings that escaped the last ecodesign round.
- IE3 — premium. The default new induction motor in most industrial power bands.
- IE4 — super premium. Reachable with a well-designed cage motor, more often with a synchronous reluctance machine or a permanent-magnet rotor.
- IE5 — ultra premium. Almost always a PM synchronous or a magnet-free SynRM. A squirrel-cage induction motor does not live here.
The comparison on this page is only as honest as the two percentages you type. Take them from the nameplate or the datasheet at the load you run, not from the class badge. An IE5 15 kW four-pole might sit around 96.5 %; an IE3 of the same rating around 92–93 %. That gap is the whole argument — and it shrinks or grows with the power band.
Why permanent-magnet synchronous motors excel at variable speed, less so at fixed speed
A PM synchronous motor has no rotor cage current in steady state. No I²R on the rotor, no slip. The field is already there, baked into the magnets. On a VFD, at part load and reduced speed, that is a gift: the induction motor still has to magnetise itself from the stator and still pays rotor copper, while the PM machine just follows the inverter frequency at unity slip.
Fixed speed, grid-direct, is a different story. The induction motor starts across the line, runs at a few percent slip, and needs nothing but a contactor. The PM synchronous motor does not: it needs an inverter to get the rotor into synchronism, and that drive has a price, a loss of its own (typically 2–3 %), and a cabinet. In fact, if the load is a fan that only ever runs at 50 Hz, the extra efficiency on the motor can be eaten by the drive you had to buy to use it. Variable-speed duty is where the PM machine earns the premium. Flat-out, all day, DOL — the induction motor is still the simpler plant.
Compactness and torque density: the synchronous motor's other advantage, beyond efficiency
Magnets put flux in the air gap without drawing magnetising current. Torque per kilogram goes up; frame size goes down. For the same shaft power you often drop a frame or two compared with an induction motor. That matters on a machine tool, a servo axis, an EV traction motor — anywhere envelope and inertia are the real constraints, not the electricity bill.
On a 15 kW pump in a plant room, compactness is a nice extra, not the reason to switch. On a 15 kW spindle that has to sit inside a casting, it can be the whole reason. The calculator on this page only prices energy and maintenance. Torque density does not show up in euros per year — it shows up in whether the motor fits.
Rare-earth magnet prices as a purchase-cost risk factor for synchronous motors
Most industrial PM rotors use neodymium-iron-boron. The magnets are a noticeable slice of the bill of materials, and NdFeB prices have a habit of jumping when export quotas or mining news hit the market. A quote you locked last year is not a quote you can count on next year. That is a purchase-cost risk the induction motor simply does not carry: copper and electrical steel move, but they do not lurch the same way.
There is a thermal risk as well. Heat a NdFeB magnet past its knee and you demagnetise it — not always reversibly. A locked-rotor event, a failed cooling fan, a poorly set VFD current limit, and the “high efficiency” motor is a paperweight. Ferrite magnets dodge the rare-earth price but give away torque density. Either way, the extra euros on the purchase order are not only “because it is IE5”. They are also a hedge you may or may not want to take.
Harsh environments (dust, temperature, load shocks): why induction motors remain dominant
A squirrel-cage rotor is a stack of bars and shorting rings. It does not mind dust, as long as the cooling fins can still breathe. It does not mind a hard start every few minutes. It will take a load shock that would make a magnet designer wince. Ambient 40 °C in a mill, a crusher with a jammed chute, a mixer that sees a slug of cold product — that is still induction-motor country.
PM machines want a clean thermal path, a current limit that is respected, and a drive that can catch the rotor. High-power ratings (hundreds of kilowatts, megawatts) stay overwhelmingly cage motors because the magnet bill, the demagnetisation risk and the inverter size all scale badly. The comparison on this page is built around a 15 kW example for a reason: that is the band where the two technologies compete. At 400 kW the question has usually already been answered.
Synchronous reluctance motors (magnet-free IE5): a third path worth its own page
A SynRM rotor has no cage worth speaking of and no magnets. Torque comes from the saliency of the iron — the rotor would rather align its easy axis with the stator field. Efficiency can reach IE4 and IE5. No rare-earth price, no demagnetisation story. The catch is the same as the PM machine: it needs a VFD, and the control is not a cheap V/f scalar drive. Torque density sits between a cage motor and a PM motor. Power factor is a bit weaker than a PM machine, so the inverter is sized a notch up.
If the hours are high, the speed varies, and you do not want magnets in the plant, this is the third column this calculator does not have. Treat it as a sibling of the PM line: same “needs a drive” logic, different bill of materials. A dedicated comparison would earn its own page — the outline is already there.
Hours per year: the lever that actually decides the comparison
Purchase price is a lump. Energy is a slope. The break-even hours on this page are just where those two lines cross. A motor that sits 500 h/year on a standby compressor will almost never pay for an IE5 premium. The same rating on a 6,000 h/year process pump will. Well, that is the whole point of typing the hours instead of arguing about technology in the abstract.
Break-even hours = extra fixed cost ÷ extra saving per hour
Fixed cost here is purchase plus maintenance over the life. The saving per hour is the difference in kWh, times the tariff. If the two efficiencies are close, or the tariff is cheap, the threshold flies off to the right — sometimes past 8,760 h, which is a polite way of saying “never”.
Part-load efficiency vs the nameplate number you typed
Nameplate efficiency is at rated load. The field on this form is an average load factor, but the calculation still uses a single η. Real motors are not that tidy. An induction motor often drops a point or two at 50 % load; a PM synchronous motor usually holds its efficiency much further down the curve. If your process lives at 40–60 % of rated torque, the IE5 gap is larger than the two nameplates suggest. If it lives at 100 %, the nameplates are fine.
Anyway, do not “correct” the typed efficiencies by guesswork. If you have a part-load curve, use the efficiency at the load you run. If you do not, the nameplate is still a better input than a round number from a catalogue class table.
Direct-on-line vs needing a VFD
An induction motor can be a contactor, an overload and a shaft. Star-delta starting or a soft starter if the inrush is a problem. A PM synchronous motor is a drive application. That drive has to be in the comparison even if this form does not have a line for it — add it to the purchase price of the synchronous column, or you are cheating.
Where a VFD is already required (variable flow, the affinity laws, a conveyor that must ramp), the drive is a sunk cost and the PM machine only has to beat the induction motor on energy and maintenance. Where the motor currently runs DOL, the drive is new money. That single fact flips more comparisons than the IE class does.
When the induction motor is still the cheaper plant choice
Keep the cage motor when the hours are low, the environment is dirty or hot, the rating is large, or you need to start across the line. Keep it when a failed magnet would stop a line you cannot afford to stop. Keep it when the stores already hold IEC frames and the electrician can swap a motor in an hour.
This page prices purchase, energy and a flat maintenance figure. It does not price downtime, spare-parts policy, drive failures, or a magnet that demagnetised after a stall. Use the break-even hours as a filter, not as a purchase order.